Observation and Design

Richard Stowey's localised view of the world.

Flickr LinkedIn Twitter RSS Feed

Is it Cheaper to Travel around London by Motorcycle or Train?

January 22nd, 2011 @ 13:37 GMT by Richard Stowey

I made the choice to get a motorcycle a while ago. There was an underlying plan to move to London where I could use the mototcycle to travel around cheaply and it would be more fun than pushing, shoving and seeing all the grumpy faces on the trains and tubes. So, now I have my Honda CB600F and AGV GP-Tech, I decided it would be quite interesting to work out whether it’s cheaper to take the motorcycle. So, is it cheaper to travel around London by motorcycle or train?

With the increase price of train and tube tickets annually in January, and with the addition this year of the VAT Increase from 17.5% to 20%, I thought it would be time well spent to work out the cheapest method of travel for getting to work.

So I calculated the cost, based on the costs which I had experienced in the past 7 months, and including things like insurance and petrol, verses the two options I have with the train system, which is either pay as you go or monthly travelcard. At this point I ruled out a yearly travelcard.

I also took into account how many working days there were per month including public holidays and any possible holiday I might take, e.g. a week in August.

The results are shown below.

londoncommutertransportcostcomparison

There are a couple of immediate observations. The most obvious is that the fixed monthly cost of the Oyster travelcard (in purple). This can act as our standard cost throughout the year. The other costs, unlike the monthly travelcard, are affected by the number of days in the month. The motorcycle costs are also affected by a set amount per month, so even if I don’t use it it’s still going to cost me. Whereas the pay as you go (PAYG) travelcard from Oyster means that I only actually pay for that journey. No other overheads.

So, when there are a low number of working days in the month, the motorcycle and PAYG win. When there are a high number of working days in the month the monthly travelcard wins. So, what this actually tells me is that for three months of the year the bike is cheaper, for four months of the year the PAYG is cheaper, and for the rest of the time, the travelcard is the cheapest. 3,4,5.

Although my calculations look fairly complex to me at the moment, working out which is cheaper gets more complicated than this. The cost of the insurance is a fixed fee which I have to pay for the whole year, whether I ride or not. So every time I take the train, it’s costing me much more. Here’s a look at the graph if I take away the insurance costs, to find out the difference:

londoncommutertransportcostcomparison-insurance

The difference now is clear, but of course it’s biased.

So taking into account my calculations for petrol cost, insurance and maintenance, travelcard and PAYG costs, there are still a couple of big exceptions if you’re looking to do the same. I’ve been riding for under a year which puts the price of insurance up quite a lot, as i get older and more experienced, gain more no claims bonus’, the cost of motorcycle insurance should decrease. My bike is carboretta fueled bike, as opposed to fuel injection, which means it’s less efficent than newer bikes. The current MPG is about 40. I don’t have to clean a travel card. I’m travelling between zones 2 and 6, and if my journey was any further or from outside of London then the train price would go up.

So if you’re looking at this, wondering whether getting the train or a motorcycle is cheaper, then I would recommend weighing up your base costs, where you live, how much motorcycling experience you have, and any other specific factors. But these shouldn’t necessarily be the driving factors, when it’s fun, enjoyable and quicker… (although that is yet to be confirmed!!)